Based on my observations between the two film representations of Ibsen's play A Doll's House, I believe that Patrick Garland's film featured a better representation of Nora. There were various aspects of Nora's character that I thought matched the way she was depicted in the play; escepicially in the portrayal of the actor.
The way that Clair Bloom embodied Nora's character was the first thing that stood out to me. As the scene opens with Nora's enterance, with her arms full of boxes and the excited expression on her face shows how she feels about her wealth. Money seems to be a very imporant factor in Nora's life. Also, the portrayal of happienss depicts how Nora is always happy on the outside, she always wants to create the effect that she is satisfied with her life, no matter what the circumstances. And even though her realtionship with Torvald was bad, she always seemed over-affectionate to Torvald, more so than in the other film, and I think that really helped the understanding of Nora's motives. I also picked up on the little affectionate games in the film that Torvald would play with Nora with money. Hanging money over her head is almost symbolic, it shows what their relationship is actually like.
The tone of Nora's voice and the delivery of the lines also played a large part in introducing Nora's character. The way Claire Bloom used changed from speaking affectionately to Torvald to seemingly helpless and needy was excellent. It shows the audience Nora's true colors and how she outwardly expresses her deceptive personality. Rather than in Schaefer's film, Julie Harris sort of had that clipped tone throughout the whole clip.
I also thought that some of the imagery in this particular film matched some of the textual description in the play as well. On the top of page 3 it mentions that the room was furnished "comfortably" and "tastefully", and in Patrick Garland's film there seemed like there was much more furniture, it looked more like a real home and taking the advantge of using colors in this film made the room seem a lot warmer and comfortable.
The lighting and camera effects worked really well in setting the scene, as compared to George Schaefer's film. In Garland's film I noticed that the use of rich tones and winter colors represented the lavish lifestyle in which Nora liked to live. Money is a very significant part to Nora's life and the rich colors show that she has no boundaries to her spendlimits and she loves it. In terms of camera effects, Garland's film was more focused on Nora and Torvald, rather than Schaefer's film, which sort of focused on Nora and her relationship with the children. However, both films were pretty straightforward with panning at Nora's enterance, as to make it clear that she is the main focus.
Although both films had very different takes on the same character, Garland's film represented Nora more affectively to the audience. Overall, Garland's film better portrayed Nora as compared to Nora character in the text.
Wednesday, September 23, 2009
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)